Firemost Pizza was founded in July of 2025 by two Hilton Head Island locals with a passion for pizza, particularly thin and crispy tavern-style pies. With a focus on innovative topping combos using the freshest ingredients, they believe great pizza starts with big flavors, be it classic crispy pepperoni cups, a fresh San Marzano tomato-based sauce, or even bolder elements on the sweet-and-spicy spectrum like peaches, locally sourced hot honey, or hot giardineira.
They think pizza and sandwiches should be exciting, delicious, and FUN, all while offering quality and consistency you can count on every visit. Whether it’s our “Honeymoon in Vegas” with that sweet-spicy kick, or a classic Italian beef sandwich dripping with jus, everything that comes out of their kitchen is made with care and a whole lot of personality. Like a LOT of personality.
Open: Wed – Sun, 4:00 PM – 9:00 PM
